Promoting People into leadership: how to avoid premature promotions

CEO of Power Inside Out | Commercial Strategy, Sales and Leadership

Do you remember your first promotion to a leadership position? Were you really prepared, or were you learning (and stumbling) along the way? These moments of uncertainty are more common than we admit, and they leave important lessons for leaders of all levels. 

A promotion to leadership positions can seem like recognition of a person's talent, commitment, or good performance. But moving up in rank doesn't always mean being ready to lead. Sometimes someone is excellent in their current role, knows the business, solves problems, and has credibility within the team.

That can lead you to think that the next natural step is to put people in charge, but the transition changes much more than it seems. The focus no longer lies solely on doing a good job and begins to include developing others, delegating, giving feedback, managing conflicts, and making decisions that impact the team.

When that preparation does not exist, a promotion that seemed like an opportunity can quickly become a source of frustration for the person and the organization.

Minha própria história: promovido pelo potencial

At the beginning of my career, I was that young and ambitious professional. My leader saw potential in me and offered me my first formal management role. I had some informal leadership experience, because I had led projects and coordinated teams, but taking on a formal leadership position was a completely new game. 

Suddenly I was responsible for guiding others, making decisions that impacted a team, and managing complex interpersonal dynamics that I had never faced before. I made many mistakes along the way. Many times I felt overwhelmed and wondered if I was truly prepared. 

What made the difference was the support I received. My manager took the time to explain the situations to me honestly and gave me guidance that, at the same time, protected and encouraged me. In addition to my manager, I had a mentor who provided me with perspective and valuable advice, and who helped me gain confidence in the role. 

Looking back, I appreciate that support system, but I also recognize how easy it would have been for things to have turned out differently. My experience is far from unique: many talented professionals face similar challenges when they are promoted based on their potential. 

Why a great specialist doesn't always want to be a manager

Think of an example like Daniel, a brilliant technical expert who is promoted to a management position for his skills. Instead of solving complex problems, Daniel now spends his days attending meetings, performing administrative tasks, and dealing with people issues. His technical talent is underutilized and he feels disconnected from the work he loves. Managing people demands too much of him and is exhausting. 

Have you ever seen a technical star have difficulties after moving away from what they do best? That doesn't mean they shouldn't grow towards leadership. It means they need the right support and time to develop the skills that the new role requires. 

A armadilha da pressão social

Why does this happen so often? Partly, it’s due to the social pressure to keep climbing up the ladder. In many organizations, success is measured by titles and promotions, rather than by satisfaction or fitting into the role. We compare ourselves with our peers, we worry about falling behind, and sometimes we say yes to roles that don’t align with our strengths or our aspirations. 

The result: talented professionals end up in positions where they feel lost, frustrated, or even exhausted. As Peter Drucker said: “Much of what we call management consists of making people’s work difficult.”. 

How to prepare a promotion to leadership positions

A promotion to leadership positions works better when it starts before the title change. Pre-preparation reduces the learning curve and allows you to assess whether the person really wants and can take on that type of responsibility.

What can we as leaders do to avoid these traps? Some practical steps: 

  • Invest in leadership development before promotion. It offers training, mentoring, and coaching before and during the transition. In this way, new leaders gain confidence and skills before facing the real challenges. 
  • Ten honest conversations. He speaks openly about career goals, strengths, and preparation before moving someone into a new role. Transparency prevents misaligned expectations and helps make decisions based on information. 
  • Redefine success. It recognizes and rewards both technical excellence and leadership. Not all people need to be managers to grow and contribute. 
  • It accompanies transitions. Provide continuous feedback and support, and remain open to changing course if the role doesn’t suit you. Sometimes, a lateral move, or even taking a step back, is the best path. 
  • Evaluate the lateral movements. It promotes and normalizes role changes that allow people to grow in roles aligned with their strengths. 
  • It promotes mentoring. In addition to the manager’s support, a mentor provides guidance, perspective, and encouragement during leadership transitions. 

A promotion should be in the right direction.

Have you experienced situations like these in your workplace? Perhaps you experienced them first-hand. What made the difference: support, training, or a great mentor? 

A promotion should lead people in the right direction, as well as upward. When we lead with empathy, clarity, and courage, we help our teams find the paths where they can give their best and feel fulfilled. 

If you are a leader facing these challenges, or if you see yourself reflected in any of these stories, you are not alone. In Power Inside Out We help leaders and organizations to navigate these transitions with confidence and care.