Leadership Development: when the leader who got you here may hold back your next stage of growth

CEO of Power Inside Out | Commercial Strategy, Sales and Leadership

“Lucas, the company is growing and I can’t keep it at the next level anymore, can you help me?” 

That call came from a CEO a few months ago. He had been working on his own development for a while, and that was precisely why he started to see something he hadn’t seen before: one of his leaders, and sometimes more than one, could no longer keep up with the company. That’s where the conversation about leadership development often begins. 

“I feel like my sales director no longer has the skills we need today,” he told me. “But he’s been there from the beginning, and he put so much into making the company what it is, that I feel like I have a commitment to him.”. 

He did not realize that that personal commitment was compromising the company and everyone who depended on that leader. 

This is not an isolated case.

It appears in all kinds of areas: 

  • The commercial leader who built the client portfolio purely through hard work. 
  • The marketing leader who built the brand from scratch. 
  • The Human Resources leader who defined the culture when there were 30 people. 

The stories are very similar: he was the best at doing the work, he was rightly promoted, and now his job is to get others to do it. It’s a different role, for which probably no one prepared them. 

What has changed is not the person. It is what your company needs.

A company of 400 people doesn’t need the same skills as one of 80. The leader who solved everything with intuition and presence now needs processes, delegation, and strategic vision. That leap is not automatic, and not everyone makes it alone. 

A sign you’ve probably already seen: the new profiles you’re hiring are increasingly senior. That makes the gap between the leader who didn’t keep up with the growth and the rest of the team more visible—and you’re no longer the only one noticing it. The entire team is starting to notice it. 

If the leader realizes on their own, there is a way out.

Very few have the self-awareness and vulnerability to recognize the gap before it becomes obvious to everyone. When it does happen, there is a huge opportunity to work on its evolution. But most of the time, That conversation is up to you to open up..

The Leadership development It also requires uncomfortable conversations about what has worked so far and what the company needs from that person going forward.

The framework for having that conversation

Get data, in addition to your opinion

One feedback 360 well-made footage clearly shows what real impact the lack of those skills has today. 

You have the conversation, as the direct leader

The conversation is up to you. You can add Human Resources if necessary, but it is important that the person directly hears from their leader what has changed, what the organization needs today, and where the gap is.

Create a concrete development plan

If there is potential and a willingness to evolve, create a clear plan. This can include mentoring, coaching, new responsibilities, or experiences that help develop the skills the role requires. The goal is to accompany a concrete transformation, not simply point out a weakness.

If nothing changes, there are two paths and both have a cost.

One is to leave it in position, minimizing the damage. You pay that cost yourself, and above all, the team pays it, which never reaches its full potential. 

The other is to move it to a different position, recognizing all that it has contributed, but understanding that what brought it here is not what your company needs for the next step. 

If you decide to move it, two important things need to happen for it to work

Rationality

Clearly explain what skills the company needs today that he or she doesn't have. This will keep him or her committed, rather than feeling like a failure. 

Ego

Think about how to move him without him feeling exposed in front of everyone. A lateral position or a new project to lead: something that allows him to continue contributing value without carrying the feeling of failure. 

Building systems, not heroes, is also your job

That no position should depend forever on the same person, regardless of whether that person grew with the pace of the company or stayed in an earlier version of it.

Developing leaders does not only consist of preparing people for future promotions; it also involves reviewing whether those who hold key positions today have the capabilities that the company needs for its next stage.

That's what we work on Power Inside Out with CEOs and leadership teams that are going through this same moment.

How many of your leaders were hired for the company you had three years ago, and not for the one you have today?