CEO of Power Inside Out | Commercial Strategy, Sales and Leadership
A bad hiring can start with a decision that, at the time, seemed completely reasonable.
“Hire slowly, fire quickly.”
That phrase stuck with me so deeply that fifteen years later I still remember exactly where I was when we had that conversation. At the time, I didn’t fully understand it. Hiring someone seemed pretty simple: interviewing smart people, choosing the best one, and moving on.
I was wrong. Over the years I hired many people in different countries, cultures, and business contexts, and I learned the hard way: hiring is one of the most difficult decisions a leader makes. When done well, it gets you a fast, agile boat capable of winning the race. When you get it wrong, a bad hire leaves you with a heavy boat that might float, or might never reach the finish line.
The fundamental problem with interviews
In an interview, the goals do not match. You, as the interviewer, want to predict how someone will perform in the future. The candidate wants you to believe that they are the best possible option.
Different goals, limited information, and very little shared context. That imbalance makes interviews inherently misleading: you try to see the real person and she shows you the best possible version of herself.
When urgency decides for you
Sometimes life doesn't give you the luxury of time. It happened to me: a freeze in hiring that was approaching, overloaded teams, and the fear of losing the position if you don't move quickly. So you hire quickly.
And a few months later it starts: comments about behavior, performance that is not up to expectations, customers or colleagues raising concerns. Suddenly, instead of leading forward, you are managing a performance problem—probably the last thing you need when the business is already under pressure.
The cost is also economical: lost productivity, management time, impact on the team and on customers, and a new selection process. In leadership positions, the hidden cost is even greater: delayed decisions, eroded trust and loss of momentum. Most companies underestimate this cost until they experience it.
Five principles to avoid bad hiring
There is no process that completely eliminates the risk of hiring the wrong person. But there are ways to make decisions with more information, fewer biases, and better signals about how that person might perform in the real role.
1. Create a truly diverse panel of interviewees
Real diversity, beyond the role: different personalities, different functions, different ways of thinking. And something very important: people who don't look like you. They will see what you don't see, because your own bias is often your silent blind spot when hiring.
2. Stop doing 30-minute interviews
If you really want to get to know someone, 30 minutes aren’t enough. In my experience, the first 20 minutes are just the shell: the rehearsed speech the candidate prepared to sell himself. Only then does the real person begin to appear.
3. Ask unconventional questions
Questions that no one has rehearsed. One of my favorites is: “What was a work situation that really went wrong?” Most candidates are unprepared to answer it, and that is exactly where their value lies. The answer says a lot about how they handle stress, how they take on responsibilities, and whether they learn from mistakes or blame others.
4. Use real and uncomfortable situations
For example: “If a project deviates and we realize that there will be an impact, how would you handle it internally and with the client?” These types of questions show how a person thinks, communicates, and prioritizes when things get complicated.
5. Test the team dynamics
For example, the question: “If you have a conflict with a difficult colleague, how would you handle it?” Culture is seen in friction, much more so than in moments of calm.
The cultural fit can define everything
Finally, and this is critical: you need to have a complete understanding of your company's culture and the priorities of your team. A candidate may look amazing in the role and still not be the right person. Skills can be trained. Behaviors and values are much more difficult to change.
However, talking about “cultural fit” can be useful, but it can also become an excuse to hire people who are too similar to one another. Culture should not function as a mold. What matters is understanding what behaviors, values, and ways of working the organization really needs, and assessing whether the person can contribute within that framework.
That also means leaving room for different perspectives. A healthy team doesn’t need identical people. It needs people who are able to work with differences, give feedback, question ideas, and contribute without breaking trust.
What to do when you already know that the hiring was incorrect
Sometimes, even with a good process, the decision doesn't work. The mistake then isn't just in hiring the wrong person. It could also be in how long it takes the organization to recognize the problem and take action.
When the signals are consistent (performance issues, sustained friction with the team, loss of trust, or a clear gap between what the role requires and what the person can bring), delaying the conversation often increases the cost.
It is important to be clear about expectations, provide concrete feedback, and open the opportunity to correct and assess whether there is real improvement. If after that process the evidence still shows that the relationship is not working, holding it indefinitely also has consequences.
The rest of the team observes which behaviors are tolerated, how long it takes to make a difficult decision, and what standards are actually upheld. Therefore, managing a bad hire is also a leadership decision.
Poor hiring costs leadership energy
Poor hiring costs much more than money: it consumes leadership energy.
At Power Inside Out, we help leaders make clear decisions about their hiring before mistakes accumulate. Most hiring failures have less to do with talent than with a lack of clarity.
Is your selection process designed to fill positions quickly or to make good decisions?
