CEO of Power Inside Out | Commercial Strategy, Sales and Leadership
One of the clearest lessons I learned about psychological safety in teams was given to me by a boss who did a very good job only part of his job.
The boss who knew how to sell upwards
He was excellent at selling upwards and was building a successful career within the corporate ladder. He had vision, energy, and a growth story that sounded incredible in his presentations.
The numbers were ambitious and the plan weak. But the narrative was good, and it worked upwards. Downwards, the story was different.
The offsite and the silence
At a time when the tension in the team was high, the company organized an offsite. One of those sessions where the space is supposedly safe and people can talk honestly.
At one point, the leader asked if we were all aligned with the growth plan.
Silence.
Most of us looked at each other without saying a word. For weeks we had been asking ourselves the same question in a low voice: How are we supposed to achieve this? No one had the answer. Neither did we, and we believed that he didn’t either, even though no one was saying it out loud.
Then one of his closest followers dared to speak up. Someone who admired him and who really wanted the plan to work. With respect, he said he wasn't sure he understood how we were going to get there.
The leader didn't take it well. He said that the key was everyone's commitment. And then he added something that I never forgot: that if someone didn't believe in the plan, maybe they should look for another company.
End of conversation.
What happened after the meeting
Later we learned that the leader had called separately to those who had the courage to speak, to ask him how he had managed to do that. How he had been able to expose it in front of everyone.
The underlying problem was leadership, much more so than strategy. That offsite, designed as a safe space, ended up functioning as a stage in front of an audience. And the question about alignment sought validation rather than honesty.
What is psychological safety in teams?
The psychological safety It is the perception that a person can speak, ask questions, admit mistakes, raise doubts, or express disagreements without fear of being punished, ridiculed, or harmed for doing so.
A team has psychological safety when its members can ask questions, raise doubts, acknowledge mistakes, and express disagreements without feeling that their place in the team is at stake.
When that is lacking, people learn quickly what it is best to keep quiet. The team seems aligned, but the problems remain there, invisible to those who have to decide.
What I learned from that silence
- Psychological safety in teams is the minimum condition for a team to function, and it is best to treat it as such rather than seeing it as a luxury or a Human Resources trend. Without it, people don’t speak. And when people don’t speak, problems go unaddressed until it’s too late.
- Selling up and leading down are two very different things. A good leader needs to do both. If you only do one, you’re building an illusion.
- Threatening those who give you feedback is the clearest sign that the leader is afraid.
- Real feedback is the best gift you can receive, because it can save you from a huge mistake that you're not seeing.
- When no one contradicts you, it is most likely that the team has learned that contradicting you comes at a cost.
How to build psychological safety in teams?
Inviting disagreement explicitly
It’s not enough to ask “what do they think?”.
Often it is more effective to ask questions that enable a critical perspective:
- What are we missing out on?
- What part of this plan doesn't convince you?
- What could go wrong?
- What information do we need to make a better decision?
That helps the disagreement stop feeling like a threat and become part of the work.
Responding well when difficult feedback comes up
If the first reaction is to justify, minimize, or defend oneself, the team quickly learns that speaking up comes at a cost. Listening, asking questions, and thanking the observer do not imply agreement. They imply that the conversation is valid.
Recognizing errors and uncertainty
A leader does not need to have all the answers to convey confidence. Saying “I don’t know,” “I was wrong,” or “I need another look at this” can also strengthen the team. When the leader shows that being wrong or not being absolutely certain is not a problem, it makes it easier for others to do the same.
Pay attention to who is speaking and who has stopped speaking
If the same people are focusing all the conversations, if some opinions disappear, or if the team starts nodding too quickly, it’s worth paying attention. Psychological safety in teams can also be read in those silences.
The end of the story
The organization changed and the leader went his own way. The plan never materialized: priorities changed and it remained in the background, as is often the case with plans that never had a real foundation.
But I took away a lesson. The less-than-good leaders I had taught me more than many of the good ones. This one, in particular, taught me exactly what not to do, and over time that really pays off.
Today I am accompanying leaders at Power Inside Out to reach their best version. Every time I work with someone on how to receive feedback or how to build teams where people really talk, I remember that silence in the offsite. A silence that said it all.
Have you ever experienced that silence after asking a question? How did you handle it?
